Mastering Bug Identification Using Git Bisect Techniques

“Beware of bugs in the above code; I have only proved it correct, not tried it.”
― Donald Knuth

---

Introduction

Through my experience debugging complex codebases and helping teams track down elusive bugs, I've found git bisect to be an invaluable tool. This guide explores how this powerful command can save developers hours of manual debugging time by using binary search to pinpoint exactly when a bug was introduced.

What is Git Bisect?

Git bisect is a debugging command that uses binary search to find the commit that introduced a bug. Instead of manually checking every commit, git bisect helps you identify the problematic commit in a logarithmic number of steps.

How Git Bisect Works Under the hood

Git bisect works by traversing Git's internal commit graph structure. Here's what happens:

• Git maintains a Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) of commits

• Each commit node contains:

  • SHA-1 hash (commit identifier)

  • Parent commit reference(s)

  • Timestamp

  • Author information

  • Complete snapshot of the codebase

When you start bisect, Git:

1. Creates a .git/BISECT_LOG file to track the bisect session

2. Stores the following information:

   • List of "good" commits

   • List of "bad" commits

   • Current bisect state

   • Reference to the original HEAD

Git uses this binary search algorithm to find the first bad commit

function findFirstBadCommit(commits):
    start = oldest_good_commit
    end = newest_bad_commit

    while (end - start) > 1:
        middle = start + (end - start) / 2
        checkout(middle)

        if user_marks_as_bad():
            end = middle
        else:
            start = middle

    return end  # First bad commit

But what makes a bad commit?

A "bad" commit in git bisect is entirely determined by YOU, the developer. There's no automatic detection - a commit is "bad" if it exhibits the problem you're trying to track down. Examples include:

• A feature stops working

• A test starts failing

• Performance degrades significantly

• UI elements render incorrectly

• The security vulnerability is present

• Any undesired behavior appears

How Git Bisect Works Over the hood

• Start the bisect process:

    git bisect start
  

• Mark the current (broken) state:

    git bisect bad
  

• Mark a known good commit:

    git bisect good <commit-hash> # you can find commit hashes using "git log
  

• G”it will automatically check commits between these points, and you mark each as 'good' or 'bad' until the problematic commit is found:

    git bisect good  # If the current commit works
    git bisect bad   # If the current commit has the bug
  

Real-World Example

Let's say you have a web application where the login button suddenly stopped working. You know it was working a month ago, but with hundreds of commits since then, finding the exact change that broke it would be like finding a needle in a haystack.

Here's how git bisect helps:

git bisect start
git bisect bad                          # Current version is broken
git bisect good release-2024-01-15      # Last known working version

# Git checks out a commit halfway between these points
# You test the login button

git bisect good                         # If it works
# OR
git bisect bad                          # If it's broken

# Repeat until Git identifies the problem commit

Best Practices

• Create a test script

  • Automate the process with git bisect run ./test-script.sh

  • Ensures consistent testing across commits

• Keep commits atomic

  • Small, focused commits make bisect more effective

  • Easier to identify exactly what change caused the issue

• Document the findings

  • Record the problematic commit and root cause

  • Share learnings with the team to prevent similar issues

Benefits

• Time Efficiency

  • Binary search is dramatically faster than linear searching

  • Find bugs in O(log n) steps instead of O(n)

• Precision

  • Pinpoints the exact commit that introduced the bug

  • Shows who made the change and why

• Learning Opportunity

  • Understanding what caused bugs helps prevent future ones

  • Improves team's code quality awareness

Conclusion

Git bisect transforms bug hunting from a tedious manual process into an efficient, systematic approach. Whether you're dealing with regression bugs, performance issues, or unexpected behavior, git bisect is your detective tool for tracking down when and why things went wrong.

Useful Bisect Commands to Remember

git bisect start              # Begin the bisect process
git bisect bad               # Mark current version as broken
git bisect good <commit>     # Mark a known good commit
git bisect reset            # End the bisect session
git bisect run <script>     # Automate the process

---

Want to learn how to create good commits?

Git in ~5 minutes